Rudy Giuliani faces potential contempt charges for allegedly repeating false claims about Georgia election workers, despite a $148 million defamation judgment against him.
At a Glance
- Giuliani owes $148 million to Georgia election workers for defamation
- Election workers seek contempt charges for alleged continued false claims
- Giuliani surrendered assets but claims political persecution
- Court hearing scheduled for December 12 to address contempt charges
- Case raises questions about balance between free speech and legal obligations
Giuliani’s Legal Troubles Escalate
Former New York City Mayor Rudy Giuliani is facing fresh legal challenges as Georgia election workers Ruby Freeman and Shaye Moss seek contempt charges against him. The election workers allege that Giuliani has continued to make false claims about them on his podcast, violating a court agreement. This development comes after Giuliani was ordered to pay $148 million in a defamation judgment to Freeman and Moss.
The legal team representing Freeman and Moss filed a motion in federal court, stating that Giuliani has persisted in making baseless accusations about the election workers. Their attorney, Michael Gottlieb, has requested that the court hold Giuliani in civil contempt and impose sanctions to ensure compliance with the existing court order.
Ex-Trump attorney Rudy Giuliani should be held in civil contempt and sanctioned for continuing to spread false claims about the 2020 election, Georgia election workers argued in a court filing Wednesday. https://t.co/27WfcS7ynU https://t.co/27WfcS7ynU
— Forbes (@Forbes) November 21, 2024
Asset Surrender and Continued Defiance
Following the $148 million judgment, Giuliani missed a court deadline to surrender assets, leading to potential civil contempt charges. In response, he turned over some assets to the election workers, including luxury watches, his New York City apartment, and a 1980s Mercedes-Benz. However, Giuliani has withheld other items and continues to claim political persecution.
“You would think that they wouldn’t be allowed to take all my property until the thing was affirmed on appeal and I got a chance to show them that they never let me show the tapes that show them quadruple counting the … ballots” – Rudy Giuliani
Despite agreeing not to accuse Freeman and Moss of election fraud, Giuliani allegedly continued to spread false claims on his live-streamed show “America’s Mayor Live.” These statements included baseless accusations about ballot counting and election machine tampering, which have been thoroughly debunked by Georgia investigators who cleared the election workers of any wrongdoing.
NEW: Ruby Freeman and Shaye Moss are seeking a contempt order against Rudy Giuliani in Washington D.C., saying the former Trump attorney violated court orders by making new defamatory statements about them last week.
w/ @eorden https://t.co/Ue36HaKIKV
— Kyle Cheney (@kyledcheney) November 20, 2024
Legal Implications and Free Speech Debate
The case against Giuliani raises important questions about the balance between free speech rights and legal obligations. Giuliani’s spokesperson, Ted Goodman, argued that the contempt motion is an attack on Giuliani’s freedom of speech. However, legal experts suggest that potential sanctions could include additional fines or even jail time if Giuliani is found in contempt of court.
“Mayor Giuliani, under the First Amendment of the Constitution, has every right to defend himself, especially as the other side consistently leaks to the press” – Ted Goodman
Giuliani’s new attorney, Joseph Cammarata, has criticized the defamation judgment as excessive and unconstitutional. The case has garnered attention from both supporters and critics of Giuliani, with some questioning the validity of the accusations against him. A court hearing is scheduled for December 12 to address the contempt charges, which could potentially lead to further legal consequences for the former mayor.
Sources:
- Georgia election workers ask judge to hold Rudy Giuliani in contempt
- Georgia election workers ask federal judge to hold Rudy Giuliani in contempt
- Poll Workers Seek Contempt Against Rudy Giuliani, Alleging Continued Defamation
- Rudy Giuliani still defaming election workers even after he was ordered to pay $148M judgment: lawyers